Show Finder

It Shoulda Been You

First Preview: Feb 23, 2015
Opening Date: Feb 23, 2015
Closing Date: Aug 9, 2015
Running Time: 02:00
It Shoulda Been You

Share on Social Media

Playing @
Lena Horne Theatre
256 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036
Emmy® and Tony Award® winner David Hyde Pierce directs an outstanding ensemble cast in IT SHOULDA BEEN YOU, the heartwarming and hilarious new musical comedy about what happens before happily ever after.
 
Tony Award® winners Tyne Daly and Harriet Harris star as the mothers of the bride and groom and the matriarchs of two very different families....... 

There's the bride who's hysterical
and the groom who's nervous
and the best man who’s daffy
and the maid of honor who’s angry
and the groom’s mother who loves her son so much it’s scary
and the bride’s mother who loves her daughters so much it’s scary
and the bride and grooms’ fathers who hide 
and Aunt Sheila who hits on waiters
and Uncle Morty who’s kind of crazy
and Albert the wedding planner who’s psychic
and at the center of it all is the bride’s sister Jenny who is determined to give her perfect sister the perfect wedding
and then the bride’s boyfriend shows up...
and that’s just the opening number. 

PERFORMANCE SCHEDULE:
TUESDAY & THURSDAY @ 7 PM
WEDNESDAY, FRIDAY & SATURDAY @ 8 PM
WEDNESDAY & SATURDAY @ 2 PM
SUNDAY @ 3 PM
BroadwayMusical
Show Notes: No Intermission
Age Guidance: 16

TDF Tickets Offers:

Listed at

Never

Full-price tickets:

$69.00 - $142.00

Video

Reviews

  • Then again, the reason for the resilience of the comedy about the wedding — be it big, fat and Greek, full of bridesmaids or otherwise — is that most of us have either had one, are relishing one or are worrying that there never will be one for us. That ease of identification, coupled with strikingly lively direction from David Hyde Pierce and a veritable plethora of superb farcical performances from the likes of Tyne Daly and Harriet Harris, explains why a great deal of the content in this show — which actually is much better than the above description implies — lands with its audience.

    ----- Chicago Tribune
  • That old popular-comedy chestnut Abie's Irish Rose is given a modern twist in the new musical It Shoulda Been You, which plays like vintage dinner theater infused with a Borscht Belt sensibility. That it nonetheless manages to be truly amusing is a testament to the talent both on and offstage: such comic pros as Tyne Daly, Harriet Harris and Edward Hibbert manage to make the hoariest of jokes uproarious, while director David Hyde Pierce has staged the proceedings with a brisk expertise that makes the 100 intermissionless minutes fly by. It’s the sort of show that practically redefines the term "guilty pleasure."

    -----Hollywood Reporter
  • Improbably, if the audience at a recent preview is an indication, this conscientiously good-humored 100-minute show may well be a demographic crowd-pleaser. The overqualified cast convinces us that everyone onstage is having a terrific time, which goes a long way toward muffling the incredulity that such a throwback has found its way back to Broadway.

    ------Variety
  • Then again, the reason for the resilience of the comedy about the wedding — be it big, fat and Greek, full of bridesmaids or otherwise — is that most of us have either had one, are relishing one or are worrying that there never will be one for us. That ease of identification, coupled with strikingly lively direction from David Hyde Pierce and a veritable plethora of superb farcical performances from the likes of Tyne Daly and Harriet Harris, explains why a great deal of the content in this show — which actually is much better than the above description implies — lands with its audience.

    ----- Chicago Tribune

Accessibility

  • Box Office

    Outer lobby. Counter 43". Floor on slight incline.
  • Curb Ramps

    SW corner of 47th St. & Broadway; SE corner of 47th St. & 8th Ave.
  • Restroom

    A unisex restroom is located on the orchestra level.
  • Elevator/Escalator

    None
  • Entrance

    No stairs at entrance. Double doors in series: 1st set (each 28.5", heavy) into outer lobby; 2nd set (each 28.5") into inner lobby.
  • Visual Assistance

    Low vision seats available in the front of the orchestra for purchase in person or on the phone.
  • Water Fountain

    Water fountain available on mezzanine level (up nineteen steps).
  • Assisted Listening System

    Headsets for sound augmentation are available at the theatre, free of charge. Photo identification is required as a deposit.
  • Wheelchair Info

    Wheelchair seating available in the rear of the orchestra section.
  • Folding Armrests

    Six (6) mobility seats with folding armrests in the orchestra, Two (2) mobility seats with folding armrests in the mezzanine, which is up 19 stairs

TDF Social Feed

TDF
TDF3 days ago

The Northeast proves to be a mecca for talented artists to put fresh spins on beloved classics and debut exciting new works. Make your summer getaway a theatrical one by...

tdfnyc3 days ago
The Northeast proves to be a mecca for talented artists to put fresh spins on beloved classics and debut exciting new works. Make your summer getaway a theatrical one by...
TDF
TDF5 days ago

We’re so proud to be nominated in collaboration with Ordinary Sunday for a 69th Annual New York Emmy Award in the Diversity/Equity/Inclusion – Short Form Content category for our Maybe...

tdfnyc5 days ago
We’re so proud to be nominated in collaboration with Ordinary Sunday for a 69th Annual New York Emmy Award in the Diversity/Equity/Inclusion - Short Form Content category for our Maybe...
TDF
TDF1 week ago
London Road from National Theatre, Ann Hampton Callaway and Liz Callaway at 54 Below, The Metropolitan Opera's I Puritani and more stream this weekend.
tdfnyc2 weeks ago
A look back at our 2026 TDF Wendy Wasserstein Project End-of-Year Celebration! Students, mentors and teachers shared moving reflections about how the program has shaped their lives and creative journeys....
TDF
TDF2 weeks ago
Matthew Morrison at 54 Below, Summerfolk from National Theatre, National Yiddish Theatre Folksbiene' Amid Falling Walls and more are available to stream this weekend.
TDF
TDF2 weeks ago

In our latest interview, “Tempress” Chasity Moore, Garnet Williams and Teddy Wilson Jr. reflect on their journeys to Broadway, the impact of representation and the future they hope to help...

tdfnyc2 weeks ago
Tony Award winner Debbie Gravitte and her son, Sam Gravitte, are spending the summer performing just four blocks apart in NYC. Read our conversation about family, theatre, and the special...
tdfnyc2 weeks ago
In our latest interview, “Tempress” Chasity Moore, Garnet Williams and Teddy Wilson Jr. reflect on their journeys to Broadway, the impact of representation and the future they hope to help...
TDF
TDF3 weeks ago
Staying inside to beat the heat? Catch these 🎭 Our top 5 picks for stage performances to stream this holiday weekend, no sunscreen required.
tdfnyc3 weeks ago
July is Disability Pride Month! This annual event commemorates the signing of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) on July 26, 1990, which prohibits discrimination based on disability and helps...
tdfnyc4 weeks ago
What began as an unexpected collaboration has become an acclaimed new play. We spoke with playwright Eliya Smith and actor Amalia Yoo about “Dad Don’t Read This”, creative trust, and...
tdfnyc4 weeks ago
Catch a new musical with a Tony nominee, a two-hander with two TV stars, a Planet of the Apes parody and more—all for $40 or less this summer! Read our...
TDF
TDF
TDF1 month ago

Tomorrow is the last day of NYC public school, so it's the perfect moment to revisit this year’s Grad Gift celebration! Last month, TDF treated more than a thousand 2026...

tdfnyc1 month ago
TDF treated more than a thousand 2026 grads to a fabulous and FREE trip to Broadway’s CATS: The Jellicle Ball! 🐱 Every year, TDF gives NYC public and charter high...
TDF
TDF1 month ago
TDF's ticketing system is down for an upgrade. We will be up and running shortly.
tdfnyc1 month ago
CATS: The Jellicle Ball co-director Zhailon Levingston shared what he hopes audiences take away from the production during Pride Month and beyond. “If you can’t find this kind of queer...
tdfnyc2 months ago
Lucky 15–that’s how many Broadway shows are currently on TDF! Act quickly—show availability changes frequently, and tickets can go fast. Visit TDF to see all 15 shows currently on membership.
tdfnyc2 months ago
Words of wisdom from Tony-winner Joshua Henry! “What is for you cannot pass you by.” #broadway #tonyawards #joshuahenry
TDF
TDF2 months ago

Thanks so much for sharing the Tony Awards with us tonight! The biggest surprise may be what a fantastic host P!NK was (though we never doubted her... yet others did)....

TDF
TDF2 months ago
And Schmigadoon wins Best Musical!
TDF
TDF2 months ago
And an award that was essentially a given: Joshua Henry as Best Actor in a Musical for his gorgeous performance in Ragtime.
TDF
TDF2 months ago
Ragtime is picking up some big awards! Caissie Levy just won for Best Actress in a Musical. Maybe they'll extend (again)?