Show Finder

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

First Preview: Nov 1, 2025
Opening Date: Nov 20, 2025
Open run
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

Share on Social Media

Playing @
Longacre Theatre
220 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036
An original, new musical comedy about timing, connections and unexpected detours.

Meet Dougal, an impossibly upbeat Brit who has just landed in New York City for the first time to attend the wedding of the father he’s never met. Meet Robin, the sister of the bride and a no-nonsense New Yorker with a lot of errands to do for the bride—including picking up the groom’s estranged son from the airport.

These two strangers begin their journey together navigating New York City, secrets and second chances. The Boston Globe raves Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) is “Irresistible! Clever, funny, and delightfully surprising!”
BroadwayMusical

Performance Schedule

Visit telecharge.com for full schedule. 


Cast
  • Sam Tutty
  • Christiani Pitts

Music
  • Jim Barne & Kit Buchan

Lyrics
  • Jim Barne & Kit Buchan

Book
  • Jim Barne & Kit Buchan

Director
  • Tim Jackson

Choreography
  • Tim Jackson

TDF Tickets Offers:

TDF Member tickets:

Not currently available for this show

Listed at

Frequently

Full-price tickets:

$79.00 - $399.00

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair Info

    Two (2) ADA compliant viewing locations with companion seating. Transfer optional.
  • Seating

    Accessible seating is located on the ground floor. Mezzanine, balcony and lower level reached only by stairs.
  • Elevator/Escalator

    There are no elevators or escalators at this theatre.
  • Parking

    Valet parking garage: Across street at Holiday Inn Hotel (on Broadway between 48th & 49th Sts.) No vans.
  • Curb Ramps

    SE corner of 48th St. & 8th Ave.; (0.5" lip) SW corner of 48th St. & Broadway.
  • Entrance

    Double doors in series: 1st set has one automatic door (35") from 48th Street to Ticket Lobby with push-button control and ramp; 2nd set (each 26", each attended by ushers) to Orchestra.
  • Box Office

    Ticket Lobby. Counter 46". Accessible pass-through with writing shelf at 32". Assistance available.
  • Restroom

    Unisex: Third floor above balcony, accessible by elevator only. ADA compliant. Door 33". Stall 108" x 99". Commode 17". Grab bars.
  • Water Fountain

    Ticket lobby. Spout 36".
  • Telephone

    Ticket lobby. Coin slot 54". Cord 30". Volume control. With TTY and electric outlet.
  • Assisted Listening System

    Occasional sign language interpreted performances.
  • Folding Armrests

    Eleven row-end seats with folding armrests.

TDF Social Feed

tdfnyc3 days ago
In summer 2025, The Public Theater unveiled its gorgeous renovation of the Delacorte Theater in Central Park. In addition to making the venue more accessible to folks with mobility challenges,...
TDF
TDF3 days ago

We’ve rounded up 10 great shows to see for $40 or less this May. Catch a new play from the acclaimed Clubbed Thumb, an immersive musical in a Brooklyn home,...

tdfnyc3 days ago
We’ve rounded up 10 great shows to see for $40 or less this May. Catch a new play from the acclaimed Clubbed Thumb, an immersive musical in a Brooklyn home,...
tdfnyc4 days ago
Yesterday, TDF hit the Drama Desk Awards red carpet and asked: “If you could travel back in time to see any Broadway production, what would it be?” Tell us your...
TDF
TDF6 days ago

Irving Berlin's Top Hat directed and choreographed by three-time Tony winner Kathleen Marshall is available to stream on Great Performances l PBS. Check that out plus MCC Theater's Miscast26, The...

tdfnyc7 days ago
We didn’t pay Betsy Aidem to say this… we swear! 👀 But we are considering making her our unofficial spokesperson. Betsy Aidem on why TDF means so much to her...
tdfnyc7 days ago
“All those little things add up to the sparkly diamond that each costume is.” Some of this year’s Tony-nominated costume designers share the details you’ll never see, from hidden references...
tdfnyc7 days ago
We were so lucky to speak with Tony nominee Hannah Cruz yesterday! ⭐️ She shared why theatre matters, not just as entertainment but as a way to understand each other....
TDF
TDF1 week ago

There are many NYC opera companies hitting high notes all year-round! In fact, this month four of the five troupes we’re highlighting have performances, including two New York premieres. Discover...

TDF
TDF2 weeks ago

Congratulations, class of 2026! Last Tuesday, NYC’s high school seniors took over the red steps at TKTS for a graduation celebration. Afterward, everyone went to see CATS: The Jellicle Ball...

TDF
TDF2 weeks ago
Suffs Musical is available to stream for FREE through Great Performances l PBS until July 31. It's one of five performances in our streaming roundup this weekend.
TDF
TDF2 weeks ago
Thank you for joining us at our Autism Friendly Performance of & Juliet!