Show Finder

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

First Preview: Nov 1, 2025
Opening Date: Nov 20, 2025
Open run
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
https://twostrangersmusical.com/
Share on Social Media
Playing @
Longacre Theatre
220 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036
View on map
View theatre details
An original, new musical comedy about timing, connections and unexpected detours.

Meet Dougal, an impossibly upbeat Brit who has just landed in New York City for the first time to attend the wedding of the father he’s never met. Meet Robin, the sister of the bride and a no-nonsense New Yorker with a lot of errands to do for the bride—including picking up the groom’s estranged son from the airport.

These two strangers begin their journey together navigating New York City, secrets and second chances. The Boston Globe raves Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) is “Irresistible! Clever, funny, and delightfully surprising!”
BroadwayMusical
Cast
  • Sam Tutty
  • Christiani Pitts
Music
  • Jim Barne & Kit Buchan
Lyrics
  • Jim Barne & Kit Buchan
Book
  • Jim Barne & Kit Buchan
Director
  • Tim Jackson
Choreographer
  • Tim Jackson

TDF Tickets Offers:

Listed at

Frequently

See TKTS Live

Full-price tickets:

$79.00 - $399.00

Buy Tickets

Related Articles

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair Info

    Three (3) ADA compliant viewing locations with companion seating. Transfer optional

  • Seating

    Accessible seating is located on the ground floor. Mezzanine, balcony and lower level reached only by stairs.

  • Elevator/Escalator

    Small elevator will not accommodate all wheelchairs. Elevator dimensions 45”w x 41”d with 32” opening

  • Curb Ramps

    SE corner of 48th St. & 8th Ave.; (0.5" lip) SW corner of 48th St. & Broadway

  • Entrance

    Double doors in series: 1st set has one automatic door (35") from 48th Street to Ticket Lobby with push-button control and ramp; 2nd set (each 26", each attended by ushers) to orchestra.

  • Box Office

    Ticket Lobby. Counter 46". Accessible pass-through with writing shelf at 32". Assistance available

  • Restroom

    Unisex: Third floor above balcony, accessible by elevator only. ADA compliant. Door 33". Stall 108" x 99". Commode 17". Grab bars

  • Water Fountain

    Ticket lobby. Spout 36"

  • Folding Armrests

    2 row-end seats with folding armrests located in the orchestra.

You Might Also Like

Browse all shows

TDF Social Feed

TDF
9 Must-See Shows Starting This August | TDF
Catch an acclaimed thriller on Broadway, a pair of new musicals and more
TDF
TDF2 days ago

The dog days of summer have arrived. But there are still a handful of intriguing new shows starting performances this August. See Ben Folds back up Lindsay Kraft in her...

View on Facebook
tdfnyc2 days ago
The dog days of summer have arrived. But there are still a handful of intriguing new shows starting performances this August. See Ben Folds back up Lindsay Kraft in her...
  • 27
  • 1
TDF
Family Summer Vocation: Debbie Gravitte and Sam Gravitte on Starring in Two Musicals Just Blocks Apart | TDF
The Tony Award winner and her son discuss their relationship and their respective roles in 'Just In Time' and 'A Walk on the Moon'
TDF
TDF5 days ago

Last chance to head back to 1969. A Walk on the Moon, the new musical set against the backdrop of Apollo 11 and Woodstock, closes Aug 22. Find tickets to...

View on Facebook
TDF
Top 5 Stage Performances to Stream This Weekend July 31-August 2 | TDF
See Christine Andreas in concert, Rosamund Pike in 'Inter Alia' and more
TDF
TDF6 days ago
Christine Andreas at 54 Below, Inter Alia from National Theatre and more are available to stream this weekend.
View on Facebook
TDF
TDF
TDF
TDF7 days ago

We spoke with Tony nominee Julia Lester about her journey from Disney+’s High School Musical: The Musical: The Series to Broadway and beyond, and her latest role in the dark...

13
View on Facebook
tdfnyc7 days ago
We spoke with Tony nominee Julia Lester about her journey from Disney+’s High School Musical: The Musical: The Series to Broadway and beyond, and her latest role in the dark...
  • 145
  • 3
TDF
TDF
TDF1 week ago

Celebrating the opening night of The Winter’s Tale at Shakespeare in the Park with a look back at TDF’s Spanish Open Caption performance of Romeo & Juliet earlier this summer....

View on Facebook
tdfnyc1 week ago
Celebrating the opening night of The Winter’s Tale at Shakespeare in the Park with a look back at TDF’s Spanish Open Caption performance of Romeo & Juliet earlier this summer....
  • 70
  • 1
TDF
+9
TDF
TDF1 week ago

Thanks for helping us kick off our new season of Autism Friendly Performances at Ragtime at Lincoln Center Theater on Sunday. This is the first of 10 Autism Family Performances...

View on Facebook
TDF
+6
TDF
TDF1 week ago

This afternoon, we rode on the "wheels of a dream" at our Autism Friendly Performance of Lincoln Center Theater's Ragtime. Here are some initial highlights. Ragtime reminds us about the...

10
View on Facebook
TDF
Summer Theatre Getaways: 16 Shows to See in the Northeast | TDF
Destination-worthy productions at lauded venues in Hudson Valley, the Berkshires and beyond
TDF
TDF2 weeks ago

The Northeast proves to be a mecca for talented artists to put fresh spins on beloved classics and debut exciting new works. Make your summer getaway a theatrical one by...

96
View on Facebook
tdfnyc2 weeks ago
The Northeast proves to be a mecca for talented artists to put fresh spins on beloved classics and debut exciting new works. Make your summer getaway a theatrical one by...
  • 159
  • 1
TDF
TDF
TDF2 weeks ago

We’re so proud to be nominated in collaboration with Ordinary Sunday for a 69th Annual New York Emmy Award in the Diversity/Equity/Inclusion – Short Form Content category for our Maybe...

6
View on Facebook
tdfnyc2 weeks ago
We’re so proud to be nominated in collaboration with Ordinary Sunday for a 69th Annual New York Emmy Award in the Diversity/Equity/Inclusion - Short Form Content category for our Maybe...
  • 103
  • 4
TDF
Top 5 Stage Performances to Stream This Weekend July 17-19 | TDF
See London Road from London's National Theatre, I Puritani at The Metropolitan Opera and more
TDF
TDF3 weeks ago
London Road from National Theatre, Ann Hampton Callaway and Liz Callaway at 54 Below, The Metropolitan Opera's I Puritani and more stream this weekend.
View on Facebook
tdfnyc3 weeks ago
A look back at our 2026 TDF Wendy Wasserstein Project End-of-Year Celebration! Students, mentors and teachers shared moving reflections about how the program has shaped their lives and creative journeys....
  • 81
  • 0
TDF
Top 5 Stage Performances to Stream This Weekend July 10-12 | TDF
See Matthew Morrison in concert, 'Summerfolk' from London's National Theatre and more
TDF
TDF4 weeks ago
Matthew Morrison at 54 Below, Summerfolk from National Theatre, National Yiddish Theatre Folksbiene' Amid Falling Walls and more are available to stream this weekend.
View on Facebook
TDF
Why 'CATS: The Jellicle Ball' Is a Dream Confirmed for its Transfemme Stars | TDF
"Tempress" Chasity Moore, Garnet Williams and Teddy Wilson Jr. discuss their journeys to Broadway in this game-changing revival
TDF
TDF4 weeks ago

In our latest interview, “Tempress” Chasity Moore, Garnet Williams and Teddy Wilson Jr. reflect on their journeys to Broadway, the impact of representation and the future they hope to help...

56
View on Facebook
tdfnyc4 weeks ago
Tony Award winner Debbie Gravitte and her son, Sam Gravitte, are spending the summer performing just four blocks apart in NYC. Read our conversation about family, theatre, and the special...
  • 63
  • 1
tdfnyc4 weeks ago
In our latest interview, “Tempress” Chasity Moore, Garnet Williams and Teddy Wilson Jr. reflect on their journeys to Broadway, the impact of representation and the future they hope to help...
  • 226
  • 6
tdfnyc1 month ago
July is Disability Pride Month! This annual event commemorates the signing of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) on July 26, 1990, which prohibits discrimination based on disability and helps...
  • 77
  • 3
tdfnyc1 month ago
What began as an unexpected collaboration has become an acclaimed new play. We spoke with playwright Eliya Smith and actor Amalia Yoo about “Dad Don’t Read This”, creative trust, and...
  • 99
  • 3
tdfnyc1 month ago
Catch a new musical with a Tony nominee, a two-hander with two TV stars, a Planet of the Apes parody and more—all for $40 or less this summer! Read our...
  • 75
  • 2
tdfnyc1 month ago
TDF treated more than a thousand 2026 grads to a fabulous and FREE trip to Broadway’s CATS: The Jellicle Ball! 🐱 Every year, TDF gives NYC public and charter high...
  • 74
  • 0