Show Finder

The Unbelievers

First Preview: Oct 13, 2026
Opening Date: Nov 5, 2026
Closing Date: Nov 29, 2026
The Unbelievers
https://www.manhattantheatreclub.com/shows/2026-27-season/the-unbelievers/
Share on Social Media
Playing @
New York City Center - Stage I
131 West 55th St, New York, NY 10019
View theatre details
Faith means believing in something. Especially when it feels impossible. As the years go by and the mystery of the sudden disappearance of Miriam and David’s teenage son remains unsolved, their blended family must figure out how to go on, relearning how to live through the ups and downs of ordinary days in their altered world.

From the Tony and Olivier Award-nominated writer Nick Payne (Constellations, Incognito) and the Tony-nominated director Knud Adams (English, Primary Trust), comes this poignant and disarmingly funny new play about the power of hope.

Presented by Manhattan Theatre Club. 
Off BroadwayPlay - Drama
Cast
  • Lauren Ambrose
  • Tom Riley
  • Jaspal Binning
  • Brittany Bradford
  • Jack DiFalco
  • Marjan Neshat
  • Nina Ross
  • Hadi Tabbal
  • Elizabeth Yeoman
Written By
  • Nick Payne
Director
  • Knud Adams

TDF Tickets Offers:

Listed at

Never

See TKTS Live

Full-price tickets:

$69.00 - $99.00

Buy Tickets

Related Articles

Accessibility

  • Assisted Listening System

    Wireless FM assistive listening devices are available free of charge with the presentation of either a driver's license or credit card. Assistive listening devices are available at coat check on the first landing on the east side of the theater.

  • Restroom

    Restrooms are located on the mezzanine lobby level and are accessible for persons in wheelchairs via the elevator.

  • Wheelchair Info

    New York City Center’s Mainstage, Stage I, Stage II and Studio 5 spaces are all wheelchair accessible. Seats for patrons with disabilities are available online, by phone, and at the box office. Please advise us at the time of ticket purchase of your particular needs. Locations are available in the first row.

  • Box Office

    The box office is in the lobby. It is wheelchair accessible.

You Might Also Like

Browse all shows

TDF Social Feed

TDF
'Slam Frank' Is Opening Off Broadway. The Creators Say Bring on the Controversy | TDF
How Andrew Fox and Joel Sinensky made a "Springtime for Hitler" for the 21st century
TDF
TDF3 days ago

Slam Frank creators Andrew Fox and Joel Sinensky aren’t afraid to push boundaries. In a new TDF Stages interview, the duo talks about creating their provocative Off-Broadway musical and trusting...

10
View on Facebook
tdfnyc3 days ago
@slamfrankmusical creators Andrew Fox and Joel Sinensky aren’t afraid to push boundaries. In a new TDF Stages interview, the duo talks about creating their provocative Off-Broadway musical and trusting audiences...
  • 0m
  • 73
tdfnyc4 days ago
A little look back at our Autism Friendly Performance of @bwaygatsby 💚✨ Thank you to everyone who came out and helped make it such a fun afternoon at the theatre!...
  • 1,089
  • 14
TDF
+9
TDF
TDF5 days ago
Thank you for joining us at our Autism Friendly Performance of The Great Gatsby! 💚
3
View on Facebook
TDF
Playwright Jocelyn Bioh and Director Whitney White Are Back on Broadway Where They Belong | TDF
The Tony-nominated team behind Jaja’s African Hair Braiding reunite for a revival of School Girls
TDF
TDF5 days ago

Jocelyn Bioh and Whitney White are back together for the Broadway revival of School Girls; Or, The African Mean Girls Play. The Tony-nominated duo sat down with TDF Stages to...

38
View on Facebook
tdfnyc5 days ago
Jocelyn Bioh and Whitney White are back together for the Broadway revival of School Girls; Or, The African Mean Girls Play at @mtc_nyc. The Tony-nominated duo sat down with...
  • 311
  • 2
TDF
TDF
TDF5 days ago

“Every show should do an autism-friendly performance. They give everything back that they’re getting from the stage.” - Thomas M. Neff Last month, we kicked off our TDF Autism Friendly...

17
View on Facebook
tdfnyc5 days ago
“Every show should do an autism-friendly performance. They give everything back that they’re getting from the stage.” - Thomas M. Neff Last month, we kicked off our TDF Autism Friendly...
  • 210
  • 3
tdfnyc6 days ago
In honor of Hispanic Heritage Month, we’re spotlighting live performances that celebrate the Hispanic diaspora. Swipe to see shows currently available to TDF Members, plus five NYC theatres that explore...
  • 115
  • 5
TDF
Top 5 Stage Performances to Stream This Weekend September 25-27 | TDF
See Holland Taylor in a pair of political plays, 'Tristan und Isolde' at The Met and more
TDF
TDF1 week ago

Here's what's streaming this weekend, all free! It's your chance for a Holland Taylor political double feature, your last opportunity to stream The Metropolitan Opera's The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier...

View on Facebook
TDF
20 New Musicals to See Beyond Broadway This Fall | TDF
Joshua Henry in a new musical he cowrote, the buzzy London transfer of Benjamin Button, John Legend's adaptation of Imitation of Life and more
TDF
TDF2 weeks ago

Looking for your next new musical? There are more than six times as many new musicals opening Off Broadway as there are on Broadway this season! Our fall preview highlights...

80
View on Facebook
tdfnyc2 weeks ago
Looking for your next new musical? There are more than six times as many new musicals opening Off Broadway as there are on Broadway this season! Our fall preview highlights...
  • 190
  • 2
tdfnyc2 weeks ago
We’re excited to welcome Tony Award winner Laura Benanti back as host of TDF’s 2026 Broadway Breakfast! Our annual fall fundraiser, celebrating the people who help make theatre accessible to...
  • 99
  • 2
TDF
TDF
TDF3 weeks ago

"Theatre is meant to be a place where everyone feels welcome." - Caissie Levy After our Autism Friendly Performance of Ragtime last month, Tony-winning star Cassie Levy shared why these...

50
View on Facebook
tdfnyc3 weeks ago
“Theatre is meant to be a place where everyone feels welcome.” - @caissielevy After our Autism Friendly Performance of Ragtime last month, Tony-winning star Cassie Levy shared why these performances...
  • 0m
  • 14
The Public Theater
+1
The Public Theater
The Public Theater3 weeks ago

Throughout the run of Ryan J. Haddad’s GOOD TIME CHARLIE, we’re partnering with TDF and Hands On to offer a variety of accessible performances, including: Open Captioned, ASL Interpreted, Mask...

16
View on Facebook
TDF
20 Shows to See Off Broadway This September | TDF
Catch ambitious new musicals, Lupita Nyong'o in a searing play, the return of a downtown favorite and more
TDF
TDF3 weeks ago

Looking for something new to see? There’s plenty opening Off Broadway this month! Catch ambitious new musicals, documentary theatre, Lupita Nyong’o in a profoundly personal new play and the return...

20
View on Facebook
tdfnyc3 weeks ago
Looking for something new to see? There’s plenty opening Off Broadway this month! Catch ambitious new musicals, documentary theatre, Lupita Nyong’o in a profoundly personal new play and the return...
  • 159
  • 0
TDF
TDF
TDF4 weeks ago

TDF Member Appreciation Weeks at TKTS Times Square are back! From now through Sunday, September 20, just identify yourself as a TDF Member to one of our Patron Services Reps...

View on Facebook
tdfnyc4 weeks ago
TDF Member Appreciation Weeks at TKTS Times Square are back! From now through Sunday, September 20, just identify yourself as a TDF Member to one of our Patron Services Reps...
  • 56
  • 0
tdfnyc4 weeks ago
Throwback to our Hadestown Autism Friendly Performance last month! We had the best time and are so glad so many of you joined us. A huge thank you to everyone...
  • 0m
  • 5
TDF
Top 5 Stage Performances to Stream This Labor Day Weekend September 4-7 | TDF
See Bryan Cranston in 'All My Sons,' Patrick Page in 'All the Devils Are Here' and more
TDF
TDF4 weeks ago
National Theatre's All My Sons lead by Bryan Cranston and Marianne Jean-Baptiste, All the Devils Are Here starring Patrick Page at McCarter Theatre Center and more stream this weekend.
1
View on Facebook
TDF
Broadway Fall Preview 2026: 15 New Shows to See | TDF
Everything you need to know about the musicals and plays starting before the end of the year
TDF
TDF1 month ago

From star-studded revivals to buzzy new musicals, there’s a lot coming to Broadway this fall. We’ve rounded up every musical and play set to begin performances before the end of...

120
View on Facebook
tdfnyc1 month ago
From star-studded revivals to buzzy new musicals, there’s a lot coming to Broadway this fall. We’ve rounded up every musical and play set to begin performances before the end of...
  • 644
  • 2